Jointli Book a scoping callScoping call

Vendor risk assessment questionnaire

A vendor risk assessment questionnaire is the list of questions you send a company before you trust it with your information, your systems or your clients. It asks what the vendor will hold, who can get to it, how they'd tell you about a breach, and what happens when the contract ends. Their answers, and the proof behind them, become your record that you checked. Many firms call it a vendor due diligence questionnaire.

Why it matters now

Picture your bookkeeping software provider having a breach on a Friday. You hear about it the following month, from a client who got a letter. Your clients don't hold the software company responsible. They hold you responsible, because you chose the vendor.

Regulators see it the same way. The SEC's amended Regulation S-P requires investment advisers, broker-dealers, investment companies and transfer agents to have written procedures for overseeing their service providers. Those procedures must make sure each provider protects customer information and tells the firm about a breach within 72 hours. Larger firms had to comply by 3 December 2025, and smaller firms by 3 June 2026. A questionnaire, and a contract clause that backs it up, is how a firm shows it did that.

First, sort your vendors

Ask three questions about each vendor:

Do they hold or see sensitive information, either yours or your clients'?

Would your work stop if they went down for a day?

Can they get into your systems, or do they hold logins to them?

Sort by the worst answer, never the average. A vendor that only scores high on one question still belongs in the top group.

Group Who belongs here What they get
Critical Yes to any question, and a failure would hurt clients or stop work All nine sections, proof checked, reviewed every year
Important Some sensitive information, but you could work around an outage Sections A to F, H and I, reviewed every year
Standard No sensitive information, no access, easy to replace Sections A and B, reviewed when something changes

The questionnaire

Below is a free questionnaire you can copy today: 40 plain questions in nine sections, with what to ask for as proof. Start by sorting your vendors, which saves you hours: the long version only goes to the ones that matter. Checking before you sign is also the cheapest time to walk away from a vendor, with no contract to unwind, no data to get back and no clients to notify.

Send the sections each vendor's group calls for. Ask for proof wherever this list says "Proof". A "yes" with no document behind it is a claim, not an answer.

A. Company and service

  1. What service will you provide to us, and which of your products does it use?
  2. In which countries is our information stored and accessed?
  3. Who is your named contact for security questions?
  4. Have you had a security incident in the last three years that affected customers? What changed afterwards?

B. The information you will hold

  1. What information of ours, or our clients', will you hold or be able to see?
  2. Is it encrypted when stored and when sent? Proof: your security overview or trust page.
  3. How long do you keep it, and will you delete it when we ask?
  4. At the end of the contract, how do you return or destroy it, and will you confirm in writing that it is done?
  5. Do you hold only what the service needs, or more?

C. Access

  1. Which of your staff can see our information, and why?
  2. Do your staff use multi-factor authentication for every system that holds our information?
  3. How often do you review who has access, and how fast is access removed when someone leaves?
  4. Will you need access to our systems? If so, how is it requested, limited and logged?

D. Security program

  1. Do you have a written information security policy, and who owns it?
  2. Do you have a recent independent report, such as a SOC 2 Type 2 report or an ISO/IEC 27001 certificate? Proof: the report or certificate, with its date and what it covers.
  3. When was your last outside penetration test, and were the serious findings fixed?
  4. How quickly do you apply critical security updates?
  5. Do your staff get security training at least once a year?

E. Incidents

  1. How quickly will you tell us about a breach that affects our information? Ask for 72 hours or less, in writing.
  2. Who will contact us, and how?
  3. Will you help us notify our clients if we need to?
  4. Do you have a written incident response plan, and when was it last tested?

F. Keeping the service running

  1. How often do you back up our information, and when did you last test a restore?
  2. How long would it take to bring the service back after a major outage?
  3. What uptime do you commit to, and what happens if you miss it?
  4. If your company closed or was sold, how would we get our information back?

G. Your own vendors

  1. Which other companies handle our information for you? Proof: your subprocessor list.
  2. Will you tell us before you add or change one?
  3. Do you hold them to the same security terms you agree with us?

H. AI

  1. Do you use AI tools on our information or to produce work for us? Which ones?
  2. Is our information used to train any AI model, yours or anyone else's?
  3. How long do those AI tools keep our information, and can it be deleted on request?
  4. Does a person check AI-assisted work before it reaches us?
  5. Will you tell us before you start using AI on our information in a new way?

I. The contract

  1. Will the contract state your security duties and the breach notice time?
  2. Can we ask follow-up questions or review your controls once a year?
  3. Will you pass on any security terms our own clients require of us?
  4. Does the contract say how our information is returned or destroyed at the end?
  5. Will you tell us if your terms of service or privacy terms change?
  6. Who at your company signs off that these answers are accurate?

Put the questionnaire to work this week

List every vendor. Include free tools and anything paid on a company card. A vendor you don't know about is the one you can't check.

Sort them. Use the three questions above. Most firms find only a handful are Critical.

Send the right sections. Give vendors two weeks to answer, and ask for the proof at the same time as the answers.

Read the answers against the proof. Then record one decision per vendor: approved, approved with conditions (say which), or not approved.

Set the next review. Every year for Critical and Important vendors, and straight away when a vendor has a breach, gets access to new information, or changes its terms.

An operations manager reviewing a vendor checklist with the vendor's account lead

Using it for vendor due diligence

Vendor due diligence is the checking you do before you sign, and the record that shows you did it. Send the questionnaire before the contract, read the answers against the proof, and file your decision with both. That file is your answer when anyone asks how you chose the vendor.

For investment advisers and the other firms covered by the SEC's amended Regulation S-P, it is also part of the written service-provider oversight the rule requires. Our Regulation S-P guide explains what the rule asks of you.

Law firms vetting an AI tool can use the same questions. The American Bar Association's Formal Opinion 512 asks lawyers to check an AI provider the way they would any outside vendor. That means its security, whether it keeps client information after the service ends, and whether it will tell them about a breach. Section H covers the AI questions.

What the questionnaire covers

The sections follow the supplier risk management outcomes in the NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 and the purpose of CIS Critical Security Control 15, Service Provider Management:

Know your suppliers and rank them by how critical they are: the sorting step (NIST CSF 2.0, GV.SC-04).

Check before you sign: Sections A to H (GV.SC-06).

Put requirements in the contract: Section I (GV.SC-05).

Include vendors in incident planning: Section E (GV.SC-08).

Assess and monitor over the whole relationship: the yearly and on-change review (GV.SC-07).

Plan for the end of the relationship: questions 8, 26 and 38 (GV.SC-10).

Look at vendors who hold sensitive data or run critical platforms: the purpose of CIS Control 15.

Questions firms ask

The questionnaire collects answers. The assessment weighs them: what could go wrong with this vendor, given how you use it, and what you'll do about it. The questionnaire is one input to the assessment.

It's strong evidence, but check what it covers. Read which services and dates are in scope and any exceptions the auditor found. A report on a product you don't use doesn't cover the one you do.

Large providers often won't answer custom questionnaires. Answer the questions yourself from their published security pages, terms and independent reports. Mark each answer as confirmed, not stated, or can't be checked. A missing answer is still a finding, and it goes in the record.

Critical and Important vendors every year. Any vendor straight away after a breach, a new kind of access, or a change to its terms.

When a questionnaire isn't enough

A questionnaire tells you what a vendor says. A cybersecurity risk assessment works out what it means for your firm: which risks could hurt your clients, which answers don't hold up against the proof, and what to fix first. How you choose and keep an eye on your vendors is assessed with the rest of your security, and AI tools sit in the same review as every other vendor. Jointli runs it live with your team, with the owners on every call, and sets the fee before we start.

Ask us about a cybersecurity risk assessment →

Built on the NIST Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 (February 2024) and CIS Critical Security Control 15, Service Provider Management.